, , , , , , ,

al-NakbaNakba Day (Arabic: يوم النكبة Yawm an-Nakba, meaning “Day of the Palestinian Catastrophe“) is generally commemorated on 15 May, the day after the Gregorian calendar date for Israeli Independence Day (Yom Ha’atzmaut). For the Palestinians it is an annual day of commemoration of the displacement that preceded and followed the Israeli Declaration of Independence in 1948.

The Palestinian Nakba catastrophe of 1948, during which Israeli forces expelled over a million Palestinians from their homeland and seized their properties. In total, 536 cities, towns and villages — 78 percent of the land of historic Palestine — were taken during the 1948 war.

The Nakba is not just a historical event, however. It remains an ongoing trauma.

British Mandate

The Exodus Of Jaffa’s Residents Via Boats, May-1948.

Palestinian human rights are assaulted daily; Palestinians still live under occupation or are barred from their homeland. Meanwhile, Israeli land and water confiscation continue, homes and lives demolished — particularly in the West Bank and the Naqab (Negev) desert.

Palestinians worldwide remain excluded and uncompensated, despite Israel’s admission to the United Nations in 1949 being preceded by its expressed willingness to abide by Resolution 194, calling for the Palestinian refugees’ repatriation and compensation.

German colony in Palestine

A German colony in Palestine received compensation from the Israeli government when settlers were forced to flee during the Nakba.

Little known, however, is that four communities in Palestine have received carefully evaluated and internationally arranged compensation for their losses. The four villages — Sarona, Wilhelma, Betlehem (not the famed Bethlehem) and Waldheim — belonged to a Christian German group called the Templers (Deutscher Tempel).

Templers are members of the Temple Society (Tempelgesellschaft), a German Protestant sect with roots in the Pietist movement of the Lutheran Church. The Templers were expelled from the church in 1858 because of their millennial beliefs. Their aim was to realize the apocalyptic visions of the prophets of Israel in the Holy Land.

Model for settlers

Sarona 1910

German (Christian) settlement in Sarona, Palestine. What used to be Sarona is now in the middle of Tel Aviv.

Sarona near Jaffa was one of the first modern agricultural settlements in Palestine (1871) and was a model for Jewish settlers. Wilhelma (1902) near Lydda, and Betlehem (1906) and Waldheim (1907) in the upper Galilee were prosperous communally-owned German agricultural settlements.

The Templers maintained their German citizenship in Palestine. Although they established a Nazi party branch in Palestine during 1933, only approximately 17 percent of the Templers were Nazi sympathizers, according to Israeli scholar Yossi Ben-Artzi. Still, most able-bodied Templer men were conscripted to fight in the German army in 1939.

During Second World War, the British Mandate government interned the German nationals in their rural villages. Some of the Templer families were then deported and interned in Australia. Others became part of three British-German prisoner exchanges of Palestine-Germans for mainly Dutch Jews from the Bergen-Belsen concentration camps.

After the war, the British military guarded the four Templer villages to protect the Germans from Jewish extremists. Nevertheless, in April 1948, a Zionist attack killed at least two persons in Waldheim and resulted in many Templers fleeing. (This pattern of attack and killing to terrorize villagers and force them to leave was perpetrated on hundreds of Palestinian Arab villages by Zionist forces during the 1948 war.)

Fate diverges

Restitution for TemplerThe displaced Templers remained in Cyprus until they were admitted to Australia and became citizens (see ‘Buying out of the Matter’: Australia’s Role in Restitution for Templer Property in Israel,’ Journal of Israeli History: Politics, Society, Culture, 24:1, 2005, pp 135-154).

Here is where the fate of the Palestinian refugees and the German Templer refugees diverge. The governments of Australia and West Germany worked together for ten years before the State of Israel agreed in 1952 to pay restitution to the German refugees for their four rural villages, as well as the Templers’ urban property holdings in Palestine. A leading agricultural economist from Stanford University valuated the Templer holdings, including all real estate, their homes and farm buildings, orchards, forest and vineyards, down to the chicken coups and pigsties.

In 1962 — ten years later — the government of Israel paid 450 million Deutsche Marks to West Germany for the “German Secular Property in Israel” belonging to the displaced and dispossessed Templers, part of which was transferred to the Commonwealth of Australia (see Australian Treaty Series 1966 No 3).

German secularEnergetic campaign

How did the German Templers obtain compensation from the State of Israel for their expropriated property in Palestine?

The Australian and German governments mounted an energetic and determined international diplomatic campaign to secure compensation from Israel for the Templars’ assets. The Australian officials were persistent and convincing. They needed the capital inflows from restitution to assist in resettling the refugees.

Australia also assumed its obligation to protect its new citizens’ property rights. For their part, the Templers actively represented themselves through documentation, presenting evidence at international forums, and persistently demanding and claiming their rights before the Australian, German and Israeli governments.

The Templers lobbied their governments, showed up at international conferences to press their case, and advocated for themselves.

TotahUnlike the Templers, diaspora Palestinians holding other citizenship have not been successful in obtaining compensation and restitution for their properties in present-day Israel. In 1949, educator Khalil Totah appealed repeatedly to the US State Department to assist him in obtaining compensation for his orange grove and lands in historic Palestine. “As an American citizen resident in the United States,” he wrote, “to whom should I turn for redress except to you?”

No public records exist of the US government attempting to obtain compensation for Totah’s or other American citizens’ property or assets seized by Israel during the 1948 war or after.


Over a million Palestinians fled or were expelled from what is now Israel in the wars of 1948 and 1967. Is there a way to negotiate their return–or at least compensation for them and their descendants?

It is tragic and ironic that United Nations members remain complicit in the suppression of the Palestinians’ human rights. Even while some states applied significant diplomatic pressure to obtain compensation for displaced European settler communities in Palestine, which included a small but significant minority that sympathized and even fought for Nazi Germany, diplomatic pressure has not been expended for the indigenous Palestinians’ rights to Nakba compensation and restitution guaranteed under international law.


Nakba Day

1948 Palestinian exodus

The Nakba: The Palestinian Catastrophe of 1948 – Lost …

Nakba – Institute for Middle East Understanding

65 Years of Palestinian Nakba

The Electronic Intifada

Al-Nakba Denial: Concealing the Catastrophe

The Catastrophe – Al Nakba – If Americans Knew

Templers (religious believers)

Global Commemoration of the Deir Yassin massacre on April 9,1948

The Divided Economy of Mandatory Palestine

Sarona, the Kirya in Tel Aviv was founded by the Templars …

Germans land in Palestine

West Germany’s Holocaust Payoff to Israel and World Jewry

How Palestine was Vanished from the Map


Ben Gurion: “We Must Expel the Arabs and Take Their Place” : Who is Pushing Whom into the Sea?

A Tale of Lies, Deceit, and Terrorism: the Birth of Israel

“They Entered our Houses, killed Women and Children Indiscriminately”: Deir Yassin Massacre

Deir Yassin Massacre Remembered

Rule by Law or Defiance

The Templar legacy

al-Nakba: the Palestinian “Catastrophe”