Intelligence in 1973 Arab-Israeli War, Panel 2
Panelists spoke about recently declassified intelligence reports from the 1973 Arab-Israeli War. They talked about factors that led to the missed call on the Arab-Israeli War of 1973…
The Central Intelligence Agency has posted hundreds of declassified and unclassified articles from its in-house journal Studies in Intelligence, in an effort to settle a lawsuit brought by a former employee, Whistleblower Jeffrey Scudder. Until recently, the CIA had resisted release of the requested articles in softcopy format (Secrecy News), but the Agency eventually relented.
Scudder, then a project manager for the CIA’s Historical Collection Division, filed a FOIA request in 2007 for 419 Studies in Intelligence articles after discovering “a stack of articles, hundreds of histories of long-dormant conflicts and operations that he concluded were still being stored in secret years after they should have been shared with the public.” During the process of filing the request, Scudder was“confronted by supervisors and accused of mishandling classified information while assembling his FOIA request. His house was raided by the FBI and his family’s computers seized. Stripped of his job and his security clearance, Scudder said he agreed to retire last year after being told that if he refused, he risked losing much of his pension.”
– Jeffrey Scudder shares his story about how his career unraveled.
Despite the agency’s harassment, Scudder carried on with his FOIA request, inevitably filing a FOIA lawsuit for the documents’ release. As part of his initial request, Scudder asked that the documents be released in electronic format – the form that they were already in. The CIA, however, continued its common practice of refusing to release soft copies of its records – ostensibly for security reasons – and told Scudder he could only have hard copies of the articles, which would cost Scudder twice as much. Scudder sued the agency, contending that the CIA was frustrating his efforts to obtain the documents –and charging him double for doing so. (See ‘Scudder v. Central Intelligence Agency’).
District Court Judge Beryl A. Howell agreed with Scudder, writing that “Where, as here, an agency asserts nearly twenty years after the passage of the E-FOIA Amendments that it cannot provide any electronic formats because of a lengthy process the agency has created, a court is required by the FOIA to evaluate that process to determine if it meets the statutorily mandated ‘reasonable efforts’ standard…[a] FOIA request for records in an existing format should not be frustrated due to the agency’s decision to adopt a production process that nonetheless renders release in that format highly burdensome.”
The CIA changed course after Judge Howell’s finding, found a “creative solution” to the problem, and posted 249 records online with the remaining 170 documents withheld in full.
Since Scudder’s case became public, the CIA has stated that it “does not retaliate or take any personnel action against employees for submitting [FOIA] requests or pursuing them in litigation,” and has, citing budget cuts, disbanded its Historical Collections Division.
While the silver lining to the CIA’s attempt to both conceal historically significant documents and intimidate Scudder is that many of the documents are now publicly available, the fact remains that many of the documents — which should have been publicly available in the first place — were posted with unnecessary redaction’s. Matthew Aid, for example, already possesses two fully declassified and unredacted articles that the CIA recently posted, with heavy redaction’s, to its website. According to Aid, “This is a typical case of the left-hand not knowing what the right-hand is doing, and just further demonstrates that the CIA’s FOIA system is urgently in need of a major overhaul.”
Jeffrey Scudder was profiled recently in the Washington Post (CIA employee’s quest to release information ‘destroyed my entire career’ by Greg Miller, July 4, 2014).
Below are some intriguing articles from the CIA’s release that caught our attention. Please comb through them – and the others – and tell us what’s worthy of note in them! [Here is the entire larger collection of declassified Studies articles].
- CIA’S INTELLIGENCE SHARING WITH CONGRESS, Document Number: 0000872641
- “Kissinger was furious, and poor Bill Colby got the full blunt of his wrath.”
- 11 SEPTEMBER 2001: WITH THE PRESIDENT, Document Number: 0001407035
- “On arguably the most important day of President Bush’s tenure, his intelligence briefing was uneventful.”
- BOOKS ABOUT THE STASI, Document Number: 0006122502
- CIA AND THE FALL OF THE SOVIET EMPIRE: THE POLITICS OF “GETTING IT RIGHT,” Document Number: 0005302423
- “I never heard a suggestion from the CIA, or the intelligence arms of the departments of defense or state, that numerous Soviets recognized a growing, systemic economic problem.”
- CIA AND THE GUATEMALA ASSASSINATION PROPOSALS, 1952-1954, Document Number: 0006142929
- ENGINEERING FOR AZORIAN, Document Number: 0005607353
- HOW KISSINGER USED INTELLIGENCE IN THE SALT NEGOTIATIONS, Document Number: 0000620552
- HOW THE IRAN-CONTRA STORY LEAKED, Document Number: 0000621341
- HOW WE ARE PERCEIVED, Document Number: 0000620599
- INTO TIBET: THE CIA’S FIRST ATOMIC SPY, Document Number: 0005543224
- MESSAGE RECEIVED – UNFORTUNATELY, Document Number: 0000619198
- MORE PAR BLOOPERS, Document Number: 0000622789
- “She possess good intrapersonal skills.” (Talks to herself; gets polite answers.)
- “He has a numbleness of mind and spirit.” (He can imagine jumping over a candle?)
- “…completed her three year trail period.” (Presumably somewhere out in the field.)
- ORIGINS AND APPLICATIONS OF NUCLEAR INTELLIGENCE, Document Number: 0001407029
- OUR MEN IN HAVANA, Document Number: 0000624340
- PHOTO INTELLIGENCE AND PUBLIC PERSUASION, Document Number: 0006122364
- PROJECT AZORIAN: THE STORY OF THE HUGHES GLOMAR EXPLORER, Document Number: 0005301269
- Psychology of Treason, Document Number: 0006183135
- “Nobody ever defected because he was happy.”
- SOVIET TELEVISION: A NEW ASSET FOR KREMLIN WATCHERS, Document Number: 0005827379
- THE CONSEQUENCES OF PERMISSIVE NEGLECT, Document Number: 0006122439
- “Classified intelligence disclosed in the press is the effective equivalent of intelligence gathered through foreign espionage.”
- THE DECLINE AND FALL OF THE SHAH, Document Number: 0000621356
Declassified Articles from Studies in Intelligence: The IC’s Journal for the Intelligence Professional
This collection of released documents consists of a selection of declassified Studies in Intelligence articles from the 1970s to 2000s. The documents reveal the CIA’s place in conducting U.S. foreign policy. The Agency cannot plan or act today without being influenced in some way by its collective past or the historical experiences that these documents describe. This collection of declassified articles includes studies on the leadership of the individual Director of Central Intelligence (DCI) and other senior Agency officers; histories of CIA directorates and their activities; tutorials on improving intelligence tradecraft; ever-changing intelligence challenges and national security threats to the U.S.; and specific events in which intelligence played a role in informing policymakers or influencing outcomes.
Studies in Intelligence, the Intelligence Community’s journal for the intelligence professional, is administered by the Agency’s Center for the Study of Intelligence. Its mission is to stimulate within the Intelligence Community the constructive discussion of important issues of the day, to expand knowledge of lessons learned from past experiences, to increase understanding of the history of the profession, and to provide readers with considered reviews of public literature concerning intelligence. Intelligence trailblazer Sherman Kent —the ‘father’ of intelligence analysis in America—created Studies in 1955 as a journal for intelligence professionals.
In the first article published in Studies, Kent called for the creation of a literature that would support the development of intelligence as a professional discipline. He said, “As long as this discipline lacks a literature, its method, its vocabulary, its body of doctrine, and even its fundamental theory run the risk of never reaching full maturity.“ Kent believed that the most important service such a literature could perform would be to record and disseminate new ideas and experiences, and build toward a cumulative understanding of the profession.
Documents in this Collection
(Documents in PDF format require the Adobe Acrobat Reader®)
More like this
- VII-210 “US Intelligence Assessments and the Reliability of Non-Soviet Warsaw Pact Armed Forces, 1946-89,” by James D. Marchio, CIA/DCI/Center for Studies in Intelligence, Studies in Intelligence Vol. 51, No 4, December 2007.
- STUDIES IN INTELLIGENCE AND THE CENTER FOR THE STUDY OF INTELLIGENCE
- JOINT INTELLIGENCE COMMITTEE CONTINUANCE OF PUBLICATION OF STUDIES OF FOREIGN AREAS, SUCH AS JOINT ARMY-NAVY INTELLIGENCE STUDIES
- /specialCollection/nwcda2/49/STUDIES IN INTELLIGENCE JAPANESE- RELATED ARTICLES/STUDIES IN INTELLIGENCE JAPANESE- RELATED ARTICLES_0003.pdf
- /specialCollection/nwcda2/49/STUDIES IN INTELLIGENCE JAPANESE- RELATED ARTICLES/STUDIES IN INTELLIGENCE JAPANESE- RELATED ARTICLES_0001.pdf
Latest CSI Products
- [PDF 18.5 MB*]
- [PDF 1.3 MB*]
- Getting to Know the President, Second Edition: Intelligence Briefings of Presidential Candidates, 1952–2004 [PDF 1.9 MB*]
- 50 Years in Langley: Recollections of the Construction of CIA’s Original Headquarters Building [PDF 1.7 MB*]
Issues of Studies in Intelligence
- [PDF 2.93MB]
- [PDF 5.6MB]
- [PDF 2.3MB]
- [PDF 5.5MB]
- Unclassified Extracts from Classified Studies Volume 58, Number 2, 2014[PDF 4.3MB]
- Unclassified Extracts from Classified Studies Volume 58, Number 1, 2014 [PDF 2.7MB]
- Unclassified Extracts from Classified Studies Volume 57, Number 4, 2013[PDF 1.5MB]
- Unclassified Extracts from Classified Studies Volume 57, Number 3, 2013 [PDF 605.2 KB*]
- Unclassified Extracts from Classified Studies Volume 57, Number 2, 2013 [PDF 4.4 MB*]
- Unclassified Extracts from Classified Studies Volume 57, Number 1, 2013 [PDF Unavailable]
- [ ]
- [ ]
- [ ]
Documents in this Collection
Documents in PDF format require the Adobe Acrobat Reader®
Browse the collection
On the Historical Collections page, or (Publications — Central Intelligence Agency – CIA), you can download pdf files of the booklet and catalog. You can also view the collection’s photos on CIA’s and its videos on stream [external link disclaimer].
Intelligence in 1973 Arab-Israeli War, Panel 1
Panelists spoke about recently declassified intelligence reports from the 1973 Arab-Israeli War.*They talked about factors that led to the missed call on the Arab-Israeli War of 1973 and considered how lessons learned from “intelligence failures,” intelligence gathering methods, as well as past and current assessments on the Middle East.*They responded to questions from the audience.
More Videos From